Peer Review
Vivat Academia operates an external peer review system based on double-anonymous peer review, whereby the identities of authors and reviewers remain concealed from one another throughout the entire evaluation process.
The purpose of peer review is to ensure the scientific quality, originality, relevance, and methodological rigour of published works. Editorial decisions are based exclusively on the scientific and academic merit of manuscripts, irrespective of the authors’ identity, institutional affiliation, nationality, academic background, or any other personal circumstance.
Manuscripts that successfully pass the Internal Editorial Evaluation described in the Editorial Process proceed to external scientific peer review.
Reviewer Selection and Review System
Research articles and review articles are evaluated by a minimum of two independent external experts, selected ad hoc on the basis of their knowledge and experience in the subject area and methodology addressed by the manuscript.
Reviewers are external to the editorial team. Individuals presenting conflicts of interest that could compromise their independence or objectivity may not participate in the evaluation process. Reviewers who consider that they lack the necessary expertise, are unable to complete the review within the established timeframe, or identify a potential conflict of interest must decline the invitation and inform the journal accordingly.
The journal takes the necessary measures to preserve the anonymity of both parties throughout the entire procedure. Authors are required to submit an anonymised version of the manuscript, while reviewers must report any circumstance that could reveal the identity of the authors or compromise the impartiality of the evaluation.
Management and Confidentiality of the Review Process
As part of an editorial workflow managed entirely through Open Journal Systems (OJS), the selection, invitation, and assignment of reviewers, the receipt of review reports, and the monitoring of successive rounds of revision are all conducted through the platform, thereby ensuring the internal traceability of the process.
Vivat Academia periodically publishes a list of individuals who have served as reviewers, without linking their identities to specific manuscripts, review reports, or editorial decisions. Such information is retained exclusively in the journal’s internal records.
Evaluation Criteria
Scientific evaluation is conducted using a standardised review form that enables reviewers to systematically assess the quality and scientific contribution of the manuscript and to substantiate their comments and recommendations. The evaluation considers, among other aspects, the following:
- originality, novelty, relevance, and contribution to scientific and academic knowledge;
- strength of the theoretical framework and the appropriateness and currency of the sources used;
- clarity of the objectives, research questions, and/or hypotheses;
- appropriateness and rigour of the methodological design and techniques employed;
- clarity, consistency, and alignment between the objectives, methodology, results, discussion, and conclusions;
- structure, coherence, and quality of scientific communication, including the title, abstract, and keywords;
- relevance and appropriate presentation of tables and figures, as well as the adequacy and currency of the bibliographic references.
The form also allows reviewers to provide qualitative comments and justify their assessment. Each reviewer submits a reasoned report and recommendation regarding the publication of the manuscript.
Editorial Decision
Peer review reports are advisory in nature. The final editorial decision rests with the Editorial Board and is made by considering the reviewers’ reports as a whole, together with compliance with the scientific and editorial criteria established by Vivat Academia. When the reports contain substantially divergent assessments or do not provide sufficient grounds for reaching a decision, the manuscript may be referred to a third independent reviewer.
The decision is communicated to the authors together with the corresponding review reports and a reasoned explanation. The decision may be one of the following:
- Accept Submission;
- Revisions Required
- Resubmit for Review;
- Decline Submission.
Review of Revised Versions
When revisions are requested, authors must submit a revised version of the manuscript accompanied by a reasoned response to the comments received, clearly indicating the changes made and, where applicable, explaining why particular recommendations have not been incorporated.
Depending on the nature and extent of the requested revisions, the revised version may be reassessed by the same reviewers or submitted to a new external peer review.
Deadlines for submitting revisions, the maximum number of review rounds, and the estimated duration of the procedure are specified in the Editorial Process.
Special Issues and Other Contributions
Articles published in thematic special issues are subject to the same double-anonymous external peer review system as articles submitted through the regular editorial workflow. The roles and responsibilities of special issue coordinators are specified in Special Issue Coordination.
Book reviews are not subject to external peer review but instead undergo editorial evaluation, as specified under Types of Contributions.